| Home
> Media > News releases >
Lengths of Stay
Consistent Differences Between Milliman & Robertson’s Pediatric Hospital Stay Guidelines and Actual Hospital Practice,
Studies Find
Contrary to Claims, Studies Show Commonly-used
Guidelines Are Not Evidence-based
Studies Find Guidelines Fall Short of Even the Nation’s Best
Managed Hospitals, the 100 Top Hospitals™
Evanston, IL, Sept. 14, 2000 — Today the HCIA-Sachs Institute
released two clinical research studies that compare the recommended
hospital stays for pediatric patients with actual pediatric hospital
stays. The studies show that the recommended hospital stay guidelines
are consistently shorter than the actual practices of the nation’s
hospitals, even the most efficient and well-managed hospitals — the 100
Top Hospitals.
The studies compare the pediatric "goal length of stay"
guidelines published by Milliman & Robertson, Inc., an actuarial
and consulting company, to actual lengths of hospital stay for 45
conditions from both a national sample of pediatric inpatient data and
100 Top Hospitals pediatric benchmarks. The studies, Comparison
of Milliman & Robertson Pediatric Length of Stay Guidelines with
Empirical Results for Inpatient Data and the 100 Top
Hospitals™ Pediatric LOS Comparison with Non-Winners and Milliman
& Robertson Guidelines, showed nearly two-thirds of
uncomplicated pediatric patients stayed in the hospital longer than
the Milliman & Robertson goals suggest. In some cases, the
hospital stays were markedly longer.
Milliman & Robertson’s pediatric hospital stay guidelines are
used by a number of major national managed care organizations.
"Managed care organizations and other insurers use published
guidelines to help determine how long patients should stay in the
hospital," said Jean Chenoweth, executive director of the
HCIA-Sachs Institute. "Milliman & Robertson recommend that
their guidelines be used only for uncomplicated cases. However,
according to the Institute’s studies, their guidelines recommend
shorter stays for some diseases in which as high as 85 percent of the
children admitted to hospitals have complications. The use of Milliman
& Robertson’s pediatric guidelines could create a huge potential
for putting the sickest children at risk unnecessarily."
Both studies were conducted using 1998 data from HCIA-Sachs’
all-payer inpatient database that contains over 3.5 million pediatric
discharges. Based on the year of data used, the studies compare
differences in actual pediatric stays prior to the implementation of
the Milliman & Robertson pediatric guidelines across the health
care industry.
About HCIA-Sachs
HCIA-Sachs leads the health care industry in providing payers,
providers, employers, consultants, and pharmaceutical companies with
relevant strategic intelligence. HCIA-Sachs supplies clients with
effective and innovative solutions for growing revenue, benchmarking
and measuring results, and understanding consumers. HCIA-Sachs'
solutions are e-enabled to streamline decision-making.
The HCIA-Sachs Institute is the research and education division of
HCIA-Sachs. The Institute is dedicated to the improvement of the
health care industry through improved information. The Institute
produces 100 Top Hospitals and Clinical Research Program
studies and publishes white papers—authoritative research reports,
often clinical or financial — that explore the impact of legislation,
new technologies, and clinical breakthroughs on the health care
industry.
The 100 Top Hospitals studies provide the benchmarks for
performance set by the nation’s health care institutions. The
objective of the program is to establish annual targets of performance
and monitor emerging trends in benchmark information while continually
enhancing the methodologies by which health care institutions are
evaluated.
Clinical Research Program studies are dedicated to identifying the
treatment patterns of 100 Top Hospitals award winners. The
Institute produces clinical research studies, in conjunction with its
Advisory Board, to improve clinical quality and delivery of care while
providing education to the health care community.
CONTACTS:
Media:
Kerry Lydon-Minton
Solucient LLC
(847) 475-7526 ext. 2112
klydon@solucient.com.com
Providers:
Jean Chenoweth
Solucient LLC
(734) 669-7941
jchenoweth@solucient.com
###
Editor's Note: Excerpts from both studies may be accessed, via
the Internet, at http://www.100TopHospitals.com.
Copies of the studies are available to the media. Please visit the
media link on the Web site’s home page or call (212) 402-5455 for
details.
Home
> Media > News releases >
Lengths of stay |