Baltimore, MD, March 8, 1999 HCIA
Inc. (NASDAQ:HCIA) today announced the results of its first annual 100 Top Cardiovascular
Hospitals study. The study identified the best-performing hospitals in each of
two categories: "Open-Heart" or Coronary Artery Bypass Graft Surgery (CABG) and
"Coronary Angioplasty" or Percutaneous Transluminal Coronary Angioplasty (PTCA).
For each category, HCIA identified the 100 best-performing hospitals in the U.S.
The 100 Top Cardiovascular Hospitals for CABGs had significantly lower
mortality and complication rates than the national peer group and had average costs per
case that were some $3,000 per case below the group. On average, patients undergoing a
CABG at a 100 Top Cardiovascular Hospital were 20 percent less likely to end up
with a tracheostomy.
The 100 Top Cardiovascular Hospitals for PTCA were 20 percent less expensive
than the peer group and, on average, did twice as many PTCAs as their peers. Patients
undergoing a PTCA at a 100 Top Cardiovascular Hospital were 50 percent less
likely to be escalated to a CABG surgery.
The study, based on a computerized review and analysis of more than 12 million Medicare
cases, used clinical and financial measures such as average length of stay, risk-adjusted
complications and mortality rates, and severity-adjusted costs per case. Additional
calculations used to measure efficiency and effectiveness included (i) the measurement of
the proportion of CABGs performed at a hospital that resulted in trachestomies and (ii)
the frequency that PTCAs resulted in CABGs.
Prior to being ranked in each category, each hospital was placed into one of three peer
groups: Teaching Hospitals with Cardiovascular Residency Programs, Teaching Hospitals
without Cardiovascular Residency Programs, and Non-Teaching Hospitals. Approximately 700
hospitals that performed at least 80 Medicare CABGs were included in the CABG analysis and
approximately 700 hospitals that performed at least 100 Medicare PTCAs were included in
the PTCA analysis. (While several hundred hospitals were included in each category, only
34 hospitals were named Top Hospitals for both CABGs and PTCAs.)
While hospitals from across the country were included in the 100 Top Cardiovascular
Hospitals, a remarkable four of five CABG programs in Cincinnati were designated as
among the 100 Top. Also, five of the seven CABG programs in Pittsburgh earned 100
Top status, as did two of four PTCA programs in Salt Lake City.
"This study is evidence that top-quality care can be delivered in a cost-effective
fashion," said Thomas P. May, assistant vice president for HCIA and an author of the
study. "Cardiovascular services have been at the forefront of hospital cost
containment initiatives for years. The hospitals, cardiologists and cardiothoracic
surgeons have responded to the challenge in many hospitals across the country and they
have raised the bar for performance of CABG and PTCA."